Divide and Profit: How to Segment Your Mailing List for Better Engagement

Divide and Profit: How to Segment Your Mailing List for Better Engagement


One of the biggest mistakes many businesses make with their mailing list is sending the same email to everyone, all of the time.

If you think about it, not every subscriber on your mailing list is equal. You’ve probably got a mix of potential customers (those that haven’t made a purchase yet), new customers (those who have just made their first purchase), loyal customers (those who have made many purchase), and former customers (those who haven’t made any purchase in a while).

On top of that, if you sell items in different categories (for example, women’s clothing, men’s clothing, and kids clothing), do you think every subscriber is interested in all of those products? Do you want to send the same message to all of these people? Of course not.

While you can’t customize an email specific to every subscriber on your list, you can create emails based on specific criteria using segmentation. In this post, we’ll look at different ways to segment your mailing list in order to increase engagement and conversions.

Segmenting Your List Based on Customer Type

Wouldn’t it be nice if, when people walked into a store, they had a label on them that indicated whether they were new to the store, had visited but never purchased, have purchased once but not again, or have purchased many things on a regular basis? If people had labels like that, the salesperson that greets them would probably say something different each time.

Many customer databases have these labels. If yours does, then you should consider segmenting your list based on these differentiations. This way, you can target your emails in a way that will convert potential customers into customers, first time customers into loyal customers, and loyal customers into brand advocates. It can be as simple as offering new customers discounts or your most loyal customers a free gift with purchase.

Segmenting Your List Based on Interests

Let’s say your online store sells pet supplies. You probably have dog owners, cat owners, hamster owners, new pet owners, elderly pet owners, and so on. Sending them all the same email campaign isn’t going to always make a sale. However, sending them a targeted ad based on their specific pet owner needs will.

This is when an interest-based segmented list comes in handy, and there are several ways you can get subscribers into the appropriate segments. You can do it based on:

  • Products they click on in your email. If the subscriber clicks on a dog leash, then you can segment them as a dog owner and send mailings about new dog products.
  • Lead magnets they subscribe through. If your online store offers free guides for different breeds of dog, and your subscriber choose the guide to Chihuahuas, then you can segment them as a small dog owner and send mailings about new products for small dogs.
  • Items they purchase. If your customer tends to buy ferret toys and hamster wheels, then you can segment them as a small animal lover and send mailings about new products pertaining to little critters.

Find out which option works best with your customer database and mailing list platform and start sending targeted mailings based on specific interests. For example, here's an email Nordstrom's sends to subscribers it knows is interested in menswear. 

Segmenting Your List Based on Interests

By segmenting your emails based on interests you’ll increase your open and click through rates and lower your unsubscribe rates as you will not be blasting products to people who are not interested in them.

Segmenting Your List Based on Location

Location can be an important segmentation for several reasons. For starters, if you have both an online store and a physical location, you may want to send emails about sales that are happening in-store, but only to people in your region. If you have customers from various countries, you may want to send country-specific promotions on shipping like Deals Direct in the example below.

Segmenting Your List Based on Location

Most mailing list service providers will have an option to segment based on location. The location is usually determined when a subscriber signed up for your mailing list. You can also use your customer database to find the current location of your customers based on billing and shipping addresses.

Segmenting Your List Based on Engagement

Last, but not least, you will need to tailor messages differently based on the subscriber’s activity. You’ve likely seen emails that say, “We’ve missed you.” These were probably from businesses whose emails you have not opened in a while. 

Most email marketing providers will allow you to create segments based on subscriber activity like Mailchimp does here:

Segmenting Your List Based on Engagement

One reason that businesses create a separate segment for inactive subscribers (those who have not opened emails in a long time) is each subscriber typically costs you money. So why pay for subscribers who are not engaging with you?

The strategy usually goes like this. You will create a segment of subscribers that have not opened their emails in a certain timeframe, say three months, six months, etc. You send just that segment of people an email that asks them to reconfirm their subscription, either to confirm they want to continue receiving your emails or to get a special discount code or a free resource (like a new style guide for example). If the subscriber does not confirm within the next week or two, they are removed from your list.

This is a great way to make sure your mailing list consists of people who want to get your emails, i.e. the people most likely to make purchases. This will always boost the ROI of your email marketing, as you’ll be paying less for your mailing list service and only sending emails to the people who want them.

Your Mailing List Service Provider’s Segmentation Options

Note that some of these segmenting options may or may not be available to you based on the mailing list service provider you have chosen. To find out what segmentation options you have available to you, you will need to refer to the features your provider offers. You can do a Google search for your mailing list provider’s name plus segmentation, segment your list, and similar keywords. If you use the following mailing list service providers - Aweber, MailChimp, Campaign Monitor or Constant Contact - you can refer to their features listings and documentation guides for more information.

How do you segment your mailing list? Share your tips in the comments!

Further reading:

Start your free 14-day trial of Shopify