The Pros and Cons of Selling on Amazon and eBay

The Pros and Cons of Selling on Amazon and eBay
Cardboard box with Amazon logo on it

At first glance, online marketplaces like Amazon and eBay seem to be a creation of mutual benefit. Ecommerce store owners gain increased exposure for their products, and the marketplaces gain an expanded product range without having to increase inventory.

On closer inspection, the mutual benefits remain, but the reality is more nuanced. Should you expand your presence beyond your online store and start selling your products on Amazon and eBay?

The answer is... it depends. A marketplace strategy may be a boon for some retailers and a bust for others. There are a lot of variables that need to be taken into consideration, including the type of products you sell, the intensity of competition in your category, marketplace fees and restrictions, and so on.

There are, however, some pros and cons that apply across the board. In this post, we’ll explore those pros and cons, so you can make the decision of whether or not to sell on marketplaces well-informed of the upsides and the downsides.

Thinking about selling on Amazon?

Eligible Shopify merchants can now list their products on Amazon.com, sync inventory between the marketplace and their Shopify store, and more by adding the Amazon sales channel.

 

Add Amazon channel

The Pros of Selling on Amazon and eBay

1. Increase Sales From a High Traffic Channel

The chief draw of selling on marketplaces such as Amazon and eBay is the scale of their online presence. Amazon draws nearly 184 million visitors a month and eBay is home to over 164 million active buyers—that’s a heck of a lot of eyeballs! And those eyeballs can translate into higher sales volumes.

According to an Amazon executive, sellers report an average 50% increase in sales when they join Amazon Marketplace.

2. Acquire New Customers

Nobody visits Amazon or eBay searching for your store. But they may be searching for—and discover—your products. Products they may not have discovered otherwise, or that they may have purchased from a competitor.

Once you’ve got a customer in the door, even if it is through a marketplace, you’ve got a chance to win repeat business through excellent service and fulfillment. This is especially the case if you’re selling products in a category that encourages frequent, repeat purchases, such as hobby supplies or fishing gear.

3. Many People Prefer Shopping Via Marketplaces

Marketplaces are all about strength in numbers. This is as true for online marketplaces as it is for real world examples like farmer’s markets, shopping malls, and food trailer parks.

The variety and all-in-one aspect of the marketplace can draw in lots of customers who prefer that kind of shopping experience. Online marketplaces also bring the additional layer of single-stream checkout and fulfilment support in order to create a seamless experience for buyers.

Cons of Selling on Amazon & eBay

While there are some significant upsides to selling on marketplaces, there are also some drawbacks that need to be considered.

1. Marketplace Fees

Setting up shop on a marketplace can potentially supercharge your sales, but it also exposes you to another cost center: marketplace fees.

Most marketplace fees are deducted as a percentage of each sale, and can vary from site to site and even category to category.

In highly commoditized, low-margin categories, the numbers may just not add up.

Before selling your products on a marketplace, you’ll want to make sure you have a good sense of your margins and a firm understanding of the marketplace’s fee structure.

2. Limited Control

While the marketplace infrastructure has many advantages, it’s important to remember that it can cut both ways. Marketplaces don’t exist to help you, but to help themselves. They want the focus to be on the products, not the sellers. And that means they might restrict the degree to which you can brand your presence, communicate with customers, dictate what items you can and cannot sell, and so on. 

Additionally, there’s nothing to stop marketplace owners—in the case of Amazon, Sears, and so on—from going around third-party sellers, identifying popular products, and stocking them themselves.

3. Keeping Inventory in Sync

A marketplace is essentially a second point of sale. And one that sometimes can’t be configured to talk to your shopping cart. In effect, both draw down the same inventory, but don’t sync with one another, making it challenging to understand your stock levels without lots of manual reconciliation.

Note: Eligible Shopify merchants can now list products on Amazon and sync their inventory automatically using the Amazon sales channel.

How to Choose a Marketplace

As you weigh the pros and cons of selling on a marketplace, it’s also worthwhile to consider which marketplace you would join.

The tempting answer is “all of them!”, but each marketplace has its own system, its own processes and limitations and quirks. Learning to navigate those can take time you probably don’t have, so it’s best to stick to one or two marketplaces unless you know you can support more.

Two of the largest and most well-known marketplaces are Amazon and eBay.

Amazon  

Amazon’s Marketplace takes the sharper retail tack, and as a retailer itself Amazon provides tools to help third-party sellers become part of a seamless shopping experience for consumers.

Some things to consider when selling on Amazon include:

  • Fulfillment by Amazon, which involves sending your inventory in bulk to Amazon and letting them handle shipping and fulfillment.
  • Amazon Prime membership, which incentivizes shoppers with free 2-day shipping, along with a reputation for fast and reliable order fulfillment.
  • Built-in comparison shopping on Amazon (for better or for worse) pits you against other sellers.
  • There is usually a monthly fee for listing your products on Amazon; referral and other fees are charged upon making a sale and vary depending on your product category (a 15% commission for most categories).

Be sure to check out the fees for selling on Amazon and factor that into your margins when you consider selling in their marketplace.

eBay

eBay, on the other hand, is a massive marketplace for buying and selling items at both fixed prices and to the highest bidder through an auction system. Where Amazon focuses on the Amazon shopping experience, eBay offers seller tools and features that make it easier for you to feature your brand in an eBay store.

Consider the following before you decide to sell on eBay:

  • eBay lets you put items items you own up for auction to the highest bidder, which will attract many shoppers who are looking for used, unique, or hard-to-find items. However, the marketplace is also great for offering items at fixed prices. In fact, contrary to what you might think, 86% of eBay's Gross Merchandise Volume is from items sold at a fixed price and 80% of the items sold on the platform are new, not used. 
  • You will need to figure out shipping and fulfillment, either by doing it on your own or working with a third party fulfillment center.
  • There is an insertion fee per listing, per category, but sellers get a fixed amount of "free listings" per month depending on their eBay account type. However there are also Advanced Listing options that you can pay for to spruce up your listing. 

Be sure to check out the fees for listing and selling on eBay if you're considering selling here.

Final Verdict

Between Amazon and eBay, when it comes to marketplaces to sell on, it really depends on what you're selling and the scale of your operation.

Keep in mind that selling through your own store doesn't mean you can't also sell your products through a marketplace as well to reap the benefits of both, nor does selling in one marketplace mean you can't also sell in another. It's just wise to take the time to figure each out one at a time.

Many successful merchants do just that—"owning" their business and brand online, while also gaining the exposure and sales from the large volume of traffic found on online marketplaces.

Want to learn more about selling on Amazon?

Stay tuned to the Shopify blog this week to take a deep dive into the world of selling on Amazon. The team will be sharing best practices for winning the buy box, navigating Amazon's CPC platform, as well as interviews with experts sharing everything you need to know about managing Amazon listings.

About the Author

Braveen Kumar is a Writer at Shopify where he develops resources to empower entrepreneurs to start and succeed in business.

Start your free 14-day trial of Shopify